Why Some Acquisitions Work and Others Get Written Down to Zero
This article is about acquisitions and why some companies are able to make acquisitions and make them work, and why some companies acquire other companies and consistently just basically write those assets down to zero.
There's many, many complex reasons on why things work and don't work. But one really important factor that needs to be considered when evaluating an acquisition, and certainly from an investor's perspective from the outside looking in, is this:
Is the acquiring company sales driven or marketing driven?
Sales Driven vs. Marketing Driven
If it's a sales driven company, then acquiring a new company with a new product and telling the salespeople, "Hey, we want you to sell it," is very different than a marketing driven company, which already has existing distribution channels.
A marketing driven company can acquire a new product and simply increase the marketing spend, and therefore that second product can sell even better. And because it already has distribution, it can just place that second product alongside the first product.
The Beverage Example
You can think of it like this: one large beverage company buys a small beverage company. That large beverage company already knows how to market a beverage and has distribution to lots of retailers.
So if they make an acquisition, they just increase the marketing spend on that small beverage and plug it into all the retailers that they have. Even though I'm simplifying it, that is a model that can work to accelerate growth.
The Enterprise Example
Now go back to the first example: a large enterprise software or enterprise hardware company. Salespeople get to make decisions around what products to sell. They're used to selling their big CRM or their big networking equipment.
And you give them some innovative new small product. Here's a new small software product that works great with CRMs. Or some small hardware product.
And guess what? They're going to look at it. Maybe they'll give it a shot. Maybe they'll talk to some customers. And when those customers say, "Hey, I need more of your core product," then that becomes the easy sell. And that new product becomes a hard sell.
If you're getting paid on commission as a salesperson, you're always going to go for the easy sell, especially if it's going to make you significantly more money per deal, because that's really what your company focuses on.
How the Product Dies
And that trickles down. If the salespeople aren't selling it, then there's not going to be enough R&D allocated to that product. And once you have no sales and no R&D, then that's a product that's going to fail. It just goes into maintenance mode, and over time, it just gets shut down.
What Investors Should Watch For
From the outside, you can't see the integration plan. But you can look for signals:
- How does the acquirer grow today? If revenue comes mostly from a direct sales force selling large deals, be skeptical of small add-on acquisitions.
- Does the acquired product keep its own sales team? A dedicated team is a sign management understands the problem. Unfortunately, this is unlikely to be a permanent solution.
- Does the new product fit existing distribution? Can it ride along with what's already being sold, and how different is this product?
- What's the track record? Look at past acquisitions. Are those products still around, growing and getting investment? Or were they quietly retired and written off?
Who Is Going to Sell It?
An acquisition is only as good as the acquirer's ability to sell what it buys. Marketing-driven companies with existing distribution can often plug in a new product and speed up its growth. Sales-driven companies, unless they change how they pay and organize their salespeople, often watch new products starve. For investors, asking "Who is actually going to sell this?" may be one of the most useful questions you can ask about any deal.